14 of the Most Valuable Toys from the 90s

During the 90s, the world was transitioning into a new era of connectivity ushered in by the Internet. The combination of companies’ decades-long experience in manufacturing paired with the cutting-edge technology of the day made for some very interesting innovations and creative products, especially when it came to children’s toys and games.

Today, some of our favorites toys and games from the 90s are worth a fortune. Use this list of extremely valuable toys as a guide next time you’re looking through old stuff at your parents’ house. Maybe you'll find an old Beanie Baby that happens to be worth $50,000.

Electronic Furby | $10,000

1998

Who could forget the great Furby craze of the late 90s? Tiger Electronics sold over 40 million Furbies during their first three years in production.

American Girl - Felicity Merriman | $7,820

1991

Originally released in 1986, customers were willing to pay premiums for these dolls and their accompanying novels.

Home Alone 2 Deluxe Talkboy | $10,000

1995

This novelty voice recorder became a must-have gadget after its prominent debut in Home Alone 2: Lost in New York.

Nintendo 64 - Launch Edition | $3,039

1996

The Nintendo 64 remains one of the most recognizable video game consoles in the world thanks to its distinct controller and top-loading cartridge system that came among a group of consoles made by other companies using CDs for their games.

Game Boy Color - Pikachu Edition | $7,550

1999

This Pokémon-themed Game Boy Color automatically made you the coolest kid in school.

Super Mario Land 2 for Game Boy | $5,000

1992

This critically-acclaimed platformer sold over 10 million copies, making it one of the most successful Game Boy games. It also introduced fan-favorite character Wario, who would go on to star in his own spin-off games.

Goldeneye 007 for N64 | $14,499

1997

Goldeneye 007 was one of the top-selling titles on the N64, thanks in part to its expansive split-screen multiplayer mode.

Power Rangers - Thunder Megazord | $4,914

1994

This original Deluxe Edition Megazord action figure would spawn a line of customizable toys.

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - Undercover Leonardo | $2,426

1994

The inconspicuous leader of the Ninja Turtles went deep undercover in a trench coat in this limited run.

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - Scratch | $5,850

1993

No Ninja Turtle toy collection is complete without Scratch, the mutant cat that has become one of the series' most sought-after action figures.

Beanie Babies


Rainbow the Chameleon | $50,000

1997

Beanie Baby collectors will spend top dollar for well-preserved toys, the rarest of which can sell for up to $50,000!

Beanie Babies


Valentina (with errors) | $29,999

1998

Some toys with errors, such as misprinted tags or a discolored nose, can sell for even more than their normal versions.

Beanie Babies


Princess Diana | $18,950

1997

This limited-edition Beanie Baby was created to raise money for Princess Diana's Memorial Fund following her death in 1997.

Beanie Babies


Valentino | $25,003

1998

Similar to his counterpart Valentina, this bear can be worth thousands with misprints and errors.

Recommended For You.

The Biggest Starbucks in the World
Architecture
New Balance's Collaboration Friendly 9060 Series
Sneakers
CES 2023 Showcases The Best New Gadgets For Pets
Technology
Kris Jenner’s $9.9 Million Relaxation Zone
Celebrity Homes
10 Futuristic Vehicles Seeking to Transform our Commutes
Cars & Rides
The Most Stunning Eco-Friendly Hotels in the World
Travel
Larger-than-Life Competition Features Angry Birds and Stormtroopers
Entertainment
Inside John Stamos' $5.8 Million Californian Paradise
Celebrity Homes
The Most Expensive Properties for Sale in 9 Different States
Home & Garden
Nike Co-Founder’s $1.55 Million Golf Retreat
Home & Garden
Gardening Lifehacks You Should be Using
Lifestyle
Find Athleisure Gear That’s Perfect For You
Fashion
How to Dress for Any Job Interview
Fashion
Middle America Has Plenty to Offer Visitors
Travel
The Bentley Mulsanne Goes Stealth
Cars & Rides
7 Instagram Pets You Must Follow
Influencers
Baseball Star Alex Rodriguez’s $4.4 Million House
Celebrity Homes
How to Reduce Dust in Your Home
Lifestyle
8 of the Most Hilarious Wildlife Photos
Outdoor Photography
The Best Smartphone Games to Play | September 2023
Games
Rip Hamilton Pays $9.2 Million to Switch Coasts
Celebrity Homes
7 Natural Pest Control Hacks for Your Home
Home & Garden
Asia’s first ‘Vertical Forest’
Architecture
How to Stick to Your New Year's Resolutions
Lifestyle
9 Ways to Shop for Quality Electronics
Shopping
8 Celebrities with Summer Homes in the Hamptons
Celebrity Homes
Celebrities Who Got Their Start on Social Media
Celebrities
The Best Pugstagrams You Need to be Following
Lifestyle
Fantastic Visions of the Future...From the 70's
Science
The Simpsons' Assassin Sneakers: Made for Real Life
Sneakers
12 Legendary Robert De Niro Performances
TV & Film
10 Celebrities and Their Pampered Pets
Celebrities
Into the Night: The Batman Collection by Puma
Sneakers
Kendall Jenner's $6.5 million Hollywood Hills Residence
Celebrity Homes
The Hotel Designed After the 1984 Winter Olympics
Art & Design
This Architect has a Remarkable List of Celebrity Clients
Celebrity Homes
10 Locations Rich in Women’s History
Culture
Free Esports Titles That Will Bruise Your Ego
Games
Hottest New Sneaker Releases | 1/13/2023 - 1/27/2023
Sneakers
Matthew Stafford Spends $11 Million on Neighboring Homes
Celebrity Homes
Beautiful Antique Roses Add Charm to Your Garden
Lifestyle
Dua Lipa's Flutur Collection from PUMA
Fashion
Best Dog Breeds For Active People
Lifestyle
The 205mph SUV from Lamborghini
Cars & Rides
See Inside America's Tallest Home
Architecture
Stewie 1 Collection by PUMA x Breanna Stewart
Women
A Guide To The Characters Of Abbott Elementary
TV & Film
How to Increase Humidity in a Dry House
Home & Garden
Learn How Electricity Actually Works
Science
The Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Memorial
Culture